Search Scott Lyons' Weblog

9.28.2006

Angled a Big Fish

Today, the Hague-based International Criminal Tribunal for the Former Yugoslavia (ICTY) sentenced the former head of the Bosnian Serb parliament, Momcilo Krajisnik, to 27 years in prison for murder, extermination, deportation, persecution, and forced transfer of Bosnian Muslims and Croats during the 1992-1995 Bosnian war, a conflict which led to the death of over 200,000 people. The trial lasted almost 30 months.

Mr. Krajisnik represents one of the highest ranking Bosnian Serbs to be brought to trial, and one of the highest ranking successful prosecutions of the ICTY in the over 10 years of its existence. This is especially important after the death in custody and sometimes embarrassing prosecutorial process of former Serbian President Slobodan Milosevic. Former Bosnian Serb President, one of the other biggest fish to be apprehended, had plead guilty and admitted responsibility for atrocities in exchange for a reduced sentence and testifying against Krajisnik. The successful prosecution of Krajisnik represents a marked change for the tribunal, which began by prosecuting the littlest of little fish and local thugs who committed war crimes because they were available and in custody, as opposed to targeting those most responsible, which was the tactic later taken by the Special Court for Sierra Leone. As the tribunal winds down (probably by 2008), it is a vital statement that those who bear the most responsibility for the atrocities will be brought to justice. The two allegedly most responsible, former Bosnian Serb leader Radovan Karadzic and former General Ratko Mladic, are still at large after 10 years because of lack of political will and action to bring them to justice. At times, they have kept open profiles, knowing that they are protected by local loyalties and sufficiently armed bodyguards. While ICTY has a long way to go in prosecuting those who bear the greatest responsibility, the sentencing of Mr. Krajisnik is a positive step.
Two issues that were raised in his sentencing are consistent themes in ICTY judgments: difficulty prosecuting genocide and the lack of life sentences for serious atrocities. Mr. Krajisnik was found guilty of crimes against humanity, but acquitted of genocide. To this point, only two Bosnian Serb commanders have been convicted of genocide. This reflects the difficulty of proving intent. A negative consequence of the legal difficulties is that the acquittals feed the Serbian propaganda that no genocide occurred in the former Yugoslavia and leaves many Bosnian Muslims feeling as if justice was not met. The second issue is that ICTY prosecutor Alan Tieger called for life imprisonment in the case. While the 27 year sentence is effectively a life sentence for the 61 year-old Krajisnik, it does not reflect the same magnitude. So far, only one person, Bosnian Serb politician Milomir Stakic, has been given a life sentence by the tribunal, but even that was reduced to 40 years upon appeal.

The big final test for the tribunal will be whether Karadzic and Mladic can be brought to trial, convicted of genocide, and given the life sentences that they deserve.

The complete summary of judgment can be found at here.

9.21.2006

A Last Post on the UNA Blog

Today is my last posting for "The People Speak" UNA-USA Weblog. To see my post for today, click here. Also, it is reposted below.

Topical Relevance

While the discussions have been critical of the Human Rights Council for its possible insufficient reforms, inaction regarding Darfur and Sri Lanka, handicap of United States noninvolvement, bias against Israel, and the sometimes general ineffective nature of the United Nations, the Council is showing itself to be an important forum for human rights topics that do not receive enough attention and an avenue for making countries publicly defend their human rights records. In only the first few days of its
second session, the Human Rights Council has already had substantive reports and discussions on violence against women, trafficking in persons, freedom of religion, freedom of opinion, racism and xenophobia, torture, arbitrary detention, summary executions, and the independence of judges and lawyers. This is just a sampling of human rights issues that the Council will monitor and facilitate awareness for the international community. The Special Rapporteurs have conducted investigations in dozens of countries in order to fulfill their important mandate to investigate, observe, and advise on these human rights topics. While the discussion of these human rights issues may not be as newsworthy as civil wars and war crimes, they do have the capacity to impact daily life on a broad scale. In the process of raising these issues, China, Singapore, an Iran were motivated to use their right of reply and defend their actions against, respectively, the Falun Gong and Baha’i, and Nepal and Jordan addressed allegations of torture. This high profile discussion lets those countries know that their actions are being actively watched. Even if the tools to punish violations of human rights go unused, is there an impact on countries just by knowing that they could be shamed and blamed? An argument could be made that “bad actors” simply do not care about international opinion, but the fact that countries are agreeing to comply with the Special Rapporteurs and look further into the allegations may indicate that there is relevance to the Human Rights Council’s work.

9.20.2006

A Critic on UN Focus on Israel

Today, as a guest blogger on the United Nations' Association "People Speak" Weblog, I posted a critic on the new UN Human Rights Council entitled "Misguided Focus" and republished below:

Misguided focus?

A consistent criticism of the previous Human Rights Commission was its gross bias against Israel. Israel was the only country subjected to a special agenda item, was the target of half of all country-specific resolutions, and was barred from participation in any regional groups. Israel was hounded, while seriously gross abuses in other States were ignored. During a 2002 session, five out of 16 resolutions on human rights violations in specific regions targeted Israel, while no other country, including Iraq, Congo, and Sierra Leone, received more than one. A challenge put to the new Human Rights Council was to be fair and to show balance in its activity regarding alleged human rights abuses. The new Council has so far not shown any improvement over the political dynamics of the previous Human Rights Commission. While the High Commissioner for Human Rights focused on violence in Darfur, Iraq and Sri Lanka in her address to the Council, the only country-specific items on the agenda for the 2nd session relate to criticism of Israel. The other general topics include discussion of the fundamental freedoms of indigenous peoples and reports on enforced or involuntary disappearances. While these are important issues, and Israel is important to discuss, the Council has diverted attention from Darfur and Sri Lanka, and instead has only given one-sided criticism against Israel. Does this bias show that the Council has not improved from the previous Commission with regards to Israel? The Council is doing a disservice by ignoring problems in the rest of the world, especially in Darfur, and may be establishing a very poor precedent.

9.19.2006

A Critic on US Support for UN

Here is my post as a guest blogger on the United Nations' Association's "People Speak" Blog for today:

Lack of U.S. support is a serious handicap

Guest blogger:Scott Lyons, member, UNA-NCA Human Rights Task Force. When President Bush addresses the General Assembly of the United Nations this morning at a time of global uncertainty on issues of Sudan, Iran, North Korea, Afghanistan, Iraq, and the Middle East, the U.S. will attempt to rally help from international institutions and foreign alliances to resolve these complex situations, especially the situation in Darfur. The U.S. seeks support from around the world. However, the U.S. withheld support from the UN Human Rights Council, the newest international institution, and there is the question as to how much this lack of support handicaps the Council’s opportunities for success. The U.S. was actively involved in the negotiations to shape the Human Rights Council, even though the U.S. often took positions at odds with much of the world. In the end, the U.S. withheld support,
citing manifold deficiencies and argued that the reforms were insufficient. The U.S. was one of only four countries to vote against the formation of the Council. Later, the U.S. chose to not stand for election to the Council, arguing that it was taking a wait and see position. It has been convincingly argued that the U.S. decision to vote against the Council was shortsighted, since the U.S. could have abstained (as did three other countries) and lodged reservations while saying that the Human Rights Council is important. Can the Human Rights Council have a full impact without the U.S. support? The U.S. has said it will work with other countries to promote human rights and considers itself a leader on the topic. However, its lack of involvement and leadership in this forum could keep the Council from being as effective as it should or could be.

9.18.2006

A Critic on the UN in Darfur

Here is my second blog entry on the United Nations Association's "People Speak" Weblog from today.

Why so Quiet on Darfur?

As the world's current greatest human rights humanitarian crisis, and likely the first genocide of the 21st Century, confronting Darfur may be the biggest test for the new Human Rights Council. However, many of the States in the Council have negative voting records in the UN General Assembly in regards to Sudan and the situation in Darfur, and some (Algeria, China, Pakistan, and Russia) were the only members of the Security Council to abstain on previous resolutions to address Darfur. Will they now take action and assume responsibility for holding the Sudanese government responsible? To this point, the Human Rights Council has been noticeably silent on the issue of Darfur, with the
special sessions purely focused on Israel and the conflict with Lebanon and the Palestinians. While the UN struggles to get the Sudanese government to accept peacekeepers, the Human Rights Council has not used its leverage and the tactics at its disposal to encourage Sudan to help end the abuses in Darfur. Is this the first sign that the political nature that led inertia in the Human Rights Commission has carried over to the new Human Rights Council? If the Human Rights Council does not take action during its second session, which began today in Geneva, it may have already rendered itself irrelevant in the fight to protect human rights. Based upon past precedent, it could be argued that the Council is unlikely to do anything and will continue business as usual. However, the Secretary-General criticized the Human Rights Council at the opening of their second session for focusing all of the attention on the Middle East while the situation in Darfur continues to get worse. In addition, Western countries have pledged to bring up the issue of Darfur everytime Israel is raised by the Arab block, and U.N. High Commissioner for Human Rights, Louise Arbour, issued a strong rebuke of the Sudnaese government. These actions should spur the necessary action by the Council and save it from being rendered useless only a few months into its existence

An Introduction To People Speak

Please look at my posting for today on the "People Speak" weblog here. I've reposted below.

Were the reforms of the UN Human Rights Council sufficient?

Earlier this year, the Member States of the United Nations created a new
Human Rights Council to replace the ineffective Commission on Human Rights. The Commission on Human Rights failed in its core mission to examine, monitor, report and respond to human rights worldwide. This was due to its structure and composition, including membership by countries accused of gross human rights abuses that could derail any attempts of public condemnation or punishment. The debate surrounding the creation of the new Human Rights Council focused on the desire for substantial reform. The UN needed the establishment of a credible body that could properly punish States that are responsible for human rights abuses, regardless of geo-strategic or border relationships. In the end, the negotiations led to a compromise. The size of the Council was reduced, but not substantially, in a modest attempt to be more effective (from 53 to 45 members). A provision for a 2/3 vote to gain membership on the Council was stripped and replaced with the requirement of a simple majority, thus possibly weakening options for excluding certain “bad actors.” In the end, Iran was not elected and Syria did not stand for election, but six countries with notoriously bad human rights records (Russia, Azerbijan, China, Pakistan, Saudi Arabia, and Cuba) were elected and almost half of the members of the Council are considered non-democratic or not-free states by Freedom House. The new Council does contain many positive provisions, including a human rights compliance review of all Member States and longer sessions to confront pressing issues. The question is whether the reforms were enough to meet the pressing issues throughout the world. The Human Rights Council faces significant challenges to “uphold the highest standards in the promotion and protection of human rights” and confront those states responsible for human rights abuses. These challenges include the situation in Darfur, suppression of rights throughout the Middle East and in former Soviet states, and successful operation without complete U.S. support. Were the reforms enough for the Council to truly have an impact on peace, security and human rights throughout the world?

A Guest Blogger

This week, the United Nations Association has asked me to be a guest blogger for its "People Speak" event. The topic I will discuss will be:

Question of the Week, September 18-22: "Will the new United Nations Human Rights Council have a positive impact on peace, security and human rights throughout the world?"

Please take a look at it all week here.

9.13.2006

American Interest

The new American policy magazine The American Interest recently included an article by Thomas Melia, Deputy Executive Director of Freedom House, which provides an overview of the government agencies and organizations that shape U.S. democracy assistance and development aid. The article, while presenting debatable policy solutions concerning the U.S. approach towards democracy promotion, gives a fairly comprehensive examination of the different players and how they work together. The article is a must-read for those who wish to better understand the methods and mechanisms at the disposal of U.S.’s push to increase democratization throughout the world.

The text of the article can be found here.

9.12.2006

A Continuation of State Formation

Today, it was confirmed that the pro-Western coalition led by Prime Minister Milo Djukanovic won last weeks election in Montenegro, the first general election vote by the newly independent Balkan state after its split from Serbia. The vote, which foreign observers from the Organization for Security and Co-Operation in Europe (OSCE) declared to be fair and largely compliant with international standards, represented an important democratic step for the country and its desire to join the European Union and NATO. Prime Minister Djukanovic’s coalition won 41 seats in the 81-seat assembly. A pro-Serbian party finished tied for second, but lost more than half of the seats that it held under the pre-independence government.

The election is a continuation of the restoration of independence in Montenegro and the formation of a state. The new parliament will be responsible for drafting and approving a new constitution. Montenegro has had to go through all the steps of state formation, as Serbia retained the United Nations seat and membership in all other international and regional organizations. However, Serbia also retained technical legal control over Kosovo, thus possibly accelerating the push for resolution of its uncertain status and demands for at least limited independence. The Kosovars have now seen their neighbors exercise independence and self-determination and will likely settle for nothing less than complete sovereignty. While the UN continues to administer Kosovo and transfer limited responsibility to local control, the quick progression of democracy in Montenegro offers a stark contrast to the unsettled status of Kosovo.

Here is a general overview of Montenegro. Here is a good discussion of Kosovo and the option of earned sovereignty as a solution for its status.

9.08.2006

A Controversial Turn in Torture Debate

This week, in strange contradictions, the U.S. displayed both the repudiation and confluence between U.S. and international law, and possibly narrowed the U.S. interpretation of the Geneva Conventions while directly applying them in other contexts. The newly proposed U.S. policies on torture and the treatment of terrorism suspects would permit the CIA to use tough, controversial, and undefined methods of interrogation on some detainees. The new approach would legitimize certain actions and provide immunity from prosecution under the War Crimes Act of 1996 for CIA interrogators who utilize extreme techniques against suspected terrorists in custody. CIA interrogators would have freedom to operate beyond the confines of the Geneva Conventions. At the same time, the U.S. military announced revisions of the Army Field Manual which would further restrict military interrogators form using questionable tactics that led to Abu Ghraib and provide Geneva Convention protections for all detainees. Both actions follow the Supreme Court’s June ruling in Hamdan v. Rumsfeld, which held that the provisions of the Geneva Conventions concerning humane treatment of prisoners applied to members of al Qaeda captured by the U.S. The result is that the U.S. military will be compliant with provisions of international law regarding treatment of prisoners and not use certain harsh tactics, while the CIA will still employ unspecified aggressive techniques.

All of this also follows the recent admission by the Bush administration that the government has indeed been rendering high profile prisoners to secret prisons throughout the world in countries that may utilize torture techniques. These so-called “black sites” have led to a European investigation that could mar transatlantic relations and marks a controversial turn in the debate over detainee rights.

Thus, the U.S. government has put itself in the awkward position, both legally and politically, of permitting tactics that have created outrage and may have damaged foreign relations, while saying unambiguously that it is illegal for anyone else to use these same techniques.

For an overview of the government debate documents related to interrogation techniques, Findlaw has a fairly detailed database.

9.07.2006

A Comment

9.02.2006

All-Female UN Peacekeeping Unit

In an “unprecedented” move, the United Nations has decided to deploy an all-female peacekeeping unit in October. While women have been included in peacekeeping contingents in the past, this marks a new phase in UN peacekeeping. The Formed Police Unit (FPU), which will be deployed in Liberia, will consist of 125 Indian women picked from the country’s paramilitary Central Reserve Police Force. These women are specially trained in crowd control and insurgency reaction, having worked in India’s flashpoints of conflict, making them more effective than a regular police force. They will be expected to help build police capacity through training of local officers as well as serving as role models for the female population of Liberia. Further, the UN contends that the all-female unit will provide access to vulnerable populations.

One question this raises is how much this unit is a response to serious allegations of abuse and sexual misconduct by other UN peacekeeping missions in the Congo and elsewhere, where peacekeepers have been investigated for everything from rape to trafficking. By increasing the deployment of women in UN police contingencies above the current 3 or 4 per cent, the gender diversity may impact a significant problem within UN peacekeeping. Even with a previous concerted effort, the UN has failed to eliminate sexual misconduct. To read more about the UN efforts to eliminate sexual abuse in peacekeeping missions, read the UN's Septemeber 1, 2006 press release.

9.01.2006

A Poster

A Campaign By Shashi Tharoor

"The person who is tipped to become the next Secretary General of the United Nations," Under-Secretary-General for Communications and Public Information Shashi Tharoor appeared on Sky News in England this evening. This represented unusual active campaigning for a position, where in the past those who were selected hardly campaigned. Under-Secretary-General has also created a website for his candidacy and has laid out a platform. The selection of Secretary-General (SG) was previously something for back-room wrangling of the powers within the Security Council, but now seems to be taking on an-American style campaign format with talking points and promotion of straw poll results.

The next SG is likely to come from Asia, due to the tradition of regional rotation and the current SG Kofi Annan coming from Africa. The last Asian SG was U Thant of Burma, who completed his second term in 1971. Thus, all of the current major candidates come from Asia, with officials from India, Korea, Thailand, supposedly leading the way.

To get nominated, a candidate must be approved by the Security Council, especially the permanent five (U.S., U.K., France, China, and Russia), who wield veto power. Thus, it will be interesting to see how the complex relationship between the home-countries of the leading candidates and the U.S. and China impacts the selection process. The U.S .has said it will back whoever emerges from the Asia caucus, but that does not mean it will not have influence, considering Kofi Annan was the U.S’s handpicked successor to Boutros-Boutros Ghali (who was effectively booted by the U.S.).

Sky News with Martin Stanford airs on weeknights between 8:00 PM and 10:00 PM in London. Presented by Martin Stanford, the show encourages viewers to contribute using webcams and 3G mobile phones to send in video messages, or join in debates regarding the issues of the day. Wikipedia offers a further biography for Martin Stanford. To read more about Sky News, read this Wikipedia entry. To read more on the news report, read this Sky News article.